Source: www.forum18.org
Date: August 31, 2026
https://www.forum18.org/archiv
By Victoria Arnold, Forum 18
A researcher for one of Russia's leading freedom of religion and belief
monitors is facing administrative prosecution after a different
organisation, deemed "undesirable" by Russia, cited her work in its own
materials. Prosecutors in the Moscow Region have charged Olga Sibiryova of
the Sova Centre for Information and Analysis with "participation in the
activities" of the International Freedom of Religion or Belief Alliance,
with which the Sova Centre says neither it nor Sibiryova has ever
interacted.
The case against Sibiryova appears to be the first under Administrative
Code Article 20.33 ("Participation in the activities of an undesirable
organisation") to be based exclusively on a citation by an "undesirable
organisation". Fines under this Article are relatively small, but a further
offence could lead to criminal prosecution with up to a 4-year jail term
(see below).
The Justice Ministry added the Sova Centre to its register of "foreign
agents" in 2016, and went to court to have it liquidated as a legal entity
in 2023. It has since operated as an unregistered group of researchers (see
below).
Forum 18 wrote to Naro-Fominsk City Prosecutor's Office and Moscow Region
Prosecutor's Office, asking which documents of the International Freedom of
Religion or Belief Alliance form the basis of the case, and why prosecutors
had initiated a case under Article 20.33 simply on the basis of an
"undesirable organisation" citing Sibiryova's publicly available reports
without her knowledge. Forum 18 received no response (see below).
Other recent prosecutions reviewed by Forum 18 appear to be based on
minimal or unknowing "participation". They include those of a Baptist
church and two Protestant higher education institutions, for continuing to
"distribute" books published by Mission Eurasia a matter of days after the
organisation – a US-based Protestant missionary body – was added to the
register of "undesirable organisations" (see below).
Krasnogorsk City Court in Moscow Region fined the pastor of a local Baptist
church, Aleksey Kruchinin, under Administrative Code Article 20.33 on 23
June. The judge also ordered that the literature confiscated from his
church – 178 copies of the New Testament and 74 booklets containing the
Gospel of St John, published by Mission Eurasia – be destroyed. The
decision went into force on 20 August when the Pastor lost his appeal (see
below).
Pastor Kruchinin's lawyer Sergey Chugunov questions the aims of decisions
to seize and destroy religious literature produced by organisations such as
Mission Eurasia. "The text of the Bible is being classified as material
from an 'undesirable' organisation simply because the book was printed by
that organisation. But does the content of the text change because of that?
Has it suddenly become a threat to public safety?" (see below).
Moscow Region Prosecutor's Office, Krasnogorsk City Court and Krasnogorsk
department of the bailiffs' service did not respond to Forum 18's questions
on why the possession of ordinary Biblical texts had been considered to be
"participation in the activities of an undesirable organisation", and
whether the books have yet been destroyed (see below).
In a 20 August court hearing when St Petersburg Christian University was
fined for having books published by Mission Eurasia in its library, the
university representative "maintained that steps had been taken to destroy
the books", according to the city courts' press service (see below).
If the General Prosecutor's Office decides that a foreign or international
organisation poses a threat in Russia's political and security sphere, it
can order it to be added to the Justice Ministry's register of "undesirable
organisations". Inclusion in this list shuts down a legal entity
immediately and bars individuals' involvement with it, even outside Russia
(see below).
"In practice, independent media outlets, as well as political, human
rights, religious, educational, research, and other projects, are
designated 'undesirable' for simply carrying out their lawful activities,"
human rights monitor OVD-Info notes. The register currently has 391
entries, including more than 20 which are religious bodies, religious
media, missionary, or educational organisations, or non-governmental
organisations with religious links or which promote freedom of religion and
belief (see below).
Charges and punishments
Administrative Code Article 20.33 punishes "Participation in the activities
of a foreign or international organisation whose activities have been
declared undesirable (https://www.forum18.org/archi
within the territory of the Russian Federation in accordance with the
legislation of the Russian Federation, or violation of prohibitions
established by Federal Law No. 272-FZ of 28 December 2012 'On Measures
Against Persons Involved in Violations of Fundamental Human Rights and
Freedoms and the Rights and Freedoms of Citizens of the Russian
Federation'".
This is punishable by the following fines: for individuals – 5,000 to
15,000 Roubles; for people in an official capacity – 20,000 to 50,000
Roubles; for legal entities – 50,000 to 100,000 Roubles; staff of
election commissions are disqualified for one year. A fine of 100,000
Roubles represents about six weeks' average wage.
A repeat offence may lead to criminal prosecution under Criminal Code
Article 284.1, Part 1 ("Participation in the activities of a foreign or
international organisation whose activities have been declared undesirable
within the territory of the Russian Federation in accordance with the
legislation of the Russian Federation, committed by a person who has been
subjected to an administrative penalty for a similar act").
Penalties for this include: a fine of 300,000 to 500,000 Roubles; up to 360
hours' compulsory labour [obyazatelniye raboty]; up to 4 years' assigned
labour [prinuditelniye raboty] with up to 2 years' possible restriction of
freedom [ogranicheniye svobody]; or 1 to 4 years' imprisonment with a
possible ban on "holding certain offices or engaging in certain activities"
for up to 10 years.
(Criminal Code Article 284.1 also includes Part 2, which covers the
financing of "undesirable organisations", and Part 3, which covers the
organisation of their activities.)
Moscow Region: "Anyone could be deemed a 'collaborator'"
On 17 August, prosecutors in the town of Naro-Fominsk in Moscow Region
charged Olga Sibiryova, a researcher at the Sova Centre for Information and
Analysis, with "participation in the activities of an undesirable
organisation" (Administrative Code Article 20.33) because an "undesirable
organisation" – the International Freedom of Religion or Belief Alliance
– had cited her work in their own reports. Naro-Fominsk City Court has
listed the first hearing of the case on 10 September, according to the
court website.
"We believe that the charge brought against Olga Sibiryova under Article
20.33 of the Administrative Code is entirely baseless", the Sova Centre
said in a statement on 17 August (https://t.me/sovacenter/507). "Neither
she personally nor the Sova Centre as a whole has ever had any interaction
with the International Freedom of Religion or Belief Alliance; the
organisation is mentioned on the Sova website solely in connection with its
designation as 'undesirable', and even then, without any value judgments
whatsoever."
Sibiryova has worked for the Sova Centre, Russia's leading organisation
monitoring freedom of religion and belief violations, for over sixteen
years. Among other work, she produces the Centre's annual reports on such
violations in Russia.
The Justice Ministry added the Sova Centre to its register of "foreign
agents" (https://www.forum18.org/archi
went to court to have it liquidated as a legal entity
(https://www.forum18.org/archi
operated as an unregistered group of researchers.
The International Freedom of Religion or Belief Alliance describes itself
(https://www.state.gov/interna
as "a network of like-minded countries fully committed to advancing freedom
of religion or belief around the world", which "brings together senior
government representatives to discuss actions their nations can take
together to promote respect for freedom of religion or belief and protect
members of religious minority groups". The US State Department coordinates
its activities.
On 25 December 2024, Russia's General Prosecutor's Office named the
Alliance an "undesirable organisation". The Justice Ministry added it to
its register of "undesirable organisations" on 17 January 2025.
On 4 August 2026, officers from the Interior Ministry's Centre for
Countering Extremism carried out an "inspection of premises" at Sibiryova's
home and seized electronic devices and books, the Sova Centre noted in its
17 August statement on the case (https://t.me/sovacenter/507).
On 17 August, Naro-Fominsk City Prosecutor's Office summoned Sibiryova for
an interview. Only then did she learn which organisation she was accused of
cooperating with, and was charged under Article 20.33. The case appears to
be based on the Alliance having allegedly cited Sibiryova's 2024 and 2025
annual reports on freedom of conscience in Russia in its own documents,
although it is unclear which documents these may be.
"This may be the first instance of an individual being accused of
collaborating with an organisation simply because that organisation cited
them. Moreover, the issue is not a matter of an expert providing specific
commentary, but rather the fact that an organisation designated as
'undesirable' has made use of publicly available material from another
project", Sova emphasised in its statement.
"And this in itself, in our view, contradicts both the letter of the law
and common sense: if this approach were applied consistently, anyone could
be deemed a 'collaborator' with an undesirable organisation – for
instance, any Russian media outlet whose material such an organisation
chose to mention on its website."
Forum 18 wrote to Naro-Fominsk City Prosecutor's Office and Moscow Region
Prosecutor's Office on 24 August, asking which documents of the
International Freedom of Religion or Belief Alliance materials form the
basis of the case, and why prosecutors had initiated a case under Article
20.33 simply on the basis of an "undesirable organisation" citing
Sibiryova's publicly available reports without her knowledge. Forum 18 had
received no response by the end of the working day in Moscow Region of 31
August.
General Prosecutor's Office names Mission Eurasia "undesirable
organisation"
Russia's General Prosecutor's Office named Mission Eurasia an "undesirable
organisation" on 30 April 2026, and the Justice Ministry added it to the
register of "undesirable organisations"
(https://www.forum18.org/archi
Mission Eurasia was founded in 1991 by American Protestant pastor Peter
Deyneka to evangelise in the former Soviet Union. It now trains local
Protestant leaders in Eastern Europe, Central Asia, and Israel, who then
engage in church planting and evangelism in workplaces and schools. It also
publishes and distributes translations of the Bible and what it calls
"strategic Christian books and resources".
"The likely reason for the organisation's inclusion on the Russian
[undesirable organisations] list is that, following the outbreak of the
full-scale war, Mission Eurasia has been actively assisting Ukraine,
documenting pressure on believers in occupied territories, criticising the
persecution of religious communities in Belarus and Russia, and reporting
on the influence of the 'Russky Mir' [Patriarch Kirill's 'Russian World'
ideology] and the Russian Orthodox Church", Christians Against War noted on
14 May (https://t.me/shaltnotkill/129
It is common for Protestant churches and educational institutions to
possess Bibles and other literature published by Mission Eurasia, even if
they have no other relationship to the organisation.
The law on "undesirable organisations" includes a ban on "the dissemination
of information materials issued by a foreign or international [undesirable]
organisation and/or disseminated by it – including via mass media and/or
using the Internet information and telecommunication network – as well as
the production or storage of such materials for the purpose of
dissemination".
Prosecutions only days after "undesirable organisation" listed, Bibles to
be destroyed?
Almost immediately after the designation of Protestant organisation Mission
Eurasia as "undesirable" in May 2026, prosecutors in Russia began seizing
books and initiating administrative cases.
Prosecutors searched a Christian bookshop in St Petersburg on 14 May, one
day after Mission Eurasia appeared on the Justice Ministry's List. St
Petersburg Christian University and the Baptist Union's Moscow Theological
Seminary were searched on 15 May, a Baptist church in the Moscow Region
town of Krasnogorsk on 23 May.
In Moscow Region ..
Krasnogorsk City Court in Moscow Region found the pastor of a local Baptist
church, Aleksey Kruchinin, guilty under Administrative Code Article 20.33
on 23 June. Judge Yekaterina Govorun handed him an unknown fine. She also
ordered that the literature confiscated from his church – 178 copies of
the New Testament and 74 booklets containing the Gospel of St John,
published by Mission Eurasia – be destroyed.
Pastor Kruchinin appealed unsuccessfully at Moscow Regional Court on 20
August. The decision entered legal force on that date, meaning that the New
Testaments and Gospels "could be destroyed at any moment", according to
Kruchinin's lawyer Sergey Chugunov. He added (https://t.me/chugunovsv/536)
that they will nevertheless continue to appeal.
"In court, we naturally pointed out that the inspection took place just ten
days after the organisation was added to the list of 'undesirable'
organisations, and that no dissemination of materials occurred during that
period – the books were kept in a locked room", Chugunov commented on his
Telegram channel (https://t.me/chugunovsv/529) shortly after Kruchinin's
guilty verdict.
Chugunov also pointed out that, in 2017, the Deputy General Prosecutor had
stated in a letter to the Culture Minister (No. 27/3-491-2015/Нд26284-17
(https://www.rba.ru/netcat_fil
that, firstly, "It is necessary to distinguish between materials that
disclose the content and results of an 'undesirable' organisation's
activities, and works by well-known authors that were merely republished or
distributed by such an organisation as part of humanitarian projects", and
secondly, "If the organisation is not the author of the works and their
content is unrelated to the activities of the 'undesirable' organisation,
the possession of such books cannot be considered a violation of the law
and does not require their seizure".
"The texts of the New Testament and the Gospel of John are widely known and
form part of the Bible. The fact that the books bear the imprint of the
'Mission Eurasia' publishing house is a technical detail", Chugunov argued.
"This raises the question: what is the aim of such decisions? The text of
the Bible is being classified as material from an 'undesirable'
organisation simply because the book was printed by that organisation. But
does the content of the text change because of that? Has it suddenly become
a threat to public safety?"
The first instance court decided that "the mere possession of printed
literature belonging to [an undesirable organisation] constitutes an
administrative offence. The lack of access to the premises where said
literature was stored does not indicate the absence of the elements of an
administrative offence", Chugunov quoted the court decision
(https://t.me/chugunovsv/536) as saying.
"The fact that the door was locked and only the pastor held the key is not
sufficient proof – you have to prove that no one had entered the room.
But did we need to? In short, that is how the hearing unfolded; the
conclusion was that everything was lawful and justified, and the ruling was
upheld", Chugunov wrote on 20 August (https://t.me/chugunovsv/536), after
Kruchinin's unsuccessful appeal.
Forum 18 wrote to Moscow Region Prosecutor's Office and Krasnogorsk City
Court on 24 August to ask why the possession of ordinary Biblical texts had
been considered to be "participation in the activities of an undesirable
organisation", especially given the General Prosecutor's Office's stance on
the matter, and whether the books have yet been destroyed.
Forum 18 also wrote to the Krasnogorsk department of the bailiffs' service
to ask whether it had destroyed the New Testaments and Gospels of John, and
if so, how this had been done. Forum 18 had received no response from any
of these agencies by the end of the working day in Moscow Region of 31
August.
.. and in St Petersburg
In St Petersburg on 20 August, Lenin District Court fined the St Petersburg
Christian University 60,000 Roubles under Administrative Code Article 20.33
for having books published by Mission Eurasia in its library two days after
the latter was added to the "undesirable organisations" register.
The university was founded by the Russian Baptist Union in Krasnodar in
1990. It moved to St Petersburg and became an interdenominational
Evangelical institution in the early 1990s. On its website, it describes
its library as "one of the best Protestant libraries in Russia", with over
28,000 books, mostly on Biblical studies.
Prosecutor's office officials seized all Mission Eurasia books from the
university library on 15 May, having determined that "any library patron
could easily obtain the material", 7x70 News reported on its Telegram
channel on 20 August (https://t.me/icerkov/9047). In court, Judge
Anastasiya Spiridonova ordered the university "permanently to cease the
dangerous dissemination of undesirable literature".
The seized books included "A Professional Mission: Achieving the Maximum
While Overcoming Challenges" and "The Alphabet of Family Worship: 55
Characteristics of God for Family Worship", which were "available for
circulation to an unlimited number of individuals upon presentation of a
library card (membership pass)", the St Petersburg court system's unified
press service stated on 20 August (https://t.me/SPbGS/24249).
"During the court hearing, the representative of the religious organisation
did not admit guilt and maintained that steps had been taken to destroy the
books", the press service added.
The day before the search of St Petersburg Christian University, just one
day after Mission Eurasia appeared on the register of "undesirable
organisations", prosecutor's office officials also inspected Slovo, a
Christian bookshop in the city. They confiscated "about 100" copies of the
Synodal translation of the Bible, published by Mission Eurasia, 7x70 News
reported on 17 May (https://t.me/icerkov/8647). According to the
booksellers, investigators told them that someone had made a complaint
against the shop.
"Shop staff emphasised that although Mission Eurasia has been designated an
undesirable organisation, the book itself is no different from other
Protestant editions", 7x70 noted in its report of the incident. "Everyone
publishes the Bible in this format," bookshop staff told the outlet. "No
matter which organisation publishes it, it is still the Bible. To us, this
feels like an insult – seizing the most affordable edition of the Bible,
the one pensioners used to buy."
Neither the shop nor any of its staff appears to have faced charges under
Administrative Code Article 20.33. It is unclear what has happened to the
confiscated books.
Forum 18 wrote to the St Petersburg Prosecutor's Office on 24 August to ask
why the presence of books published by Mission Eurasia was considered an
administrative offence only one or two days after Mission Eurasia was added
to the register of "undesirable organisations", and what has happened to
the books seized in the inspections. Forum 18 had received no response by
the end of the working day in St Petersburg of 31 August.
.. and in Moscow
In Moscow, prosecutors accused another Protestant educational institution
– the Baptist Union's Moscow Theological Seminary – of "participation"
in Mission Eurasia activities because of the books in its library. In this
case, however, they brought the charge against the seminary's rector,
rather than against the institution itself.
Moscow's Perovo District Court found Pyotr Mitskevich (who is also head of
the Russian Baptist Union) guilty under Article 20.33 on 20 July 2026.
According to the court decision, seen by Forum 18, he received the minimum
fine for a person in an official capacity, which is 20,000 Roubles. He
"agreed with the charge" and has not appealed.
The Prosecutor's Office of Moscow's Eastern Administrative Okrug carried
out an inspection of the Moscow Theological Seminary's library and reading
room on 15 May. This "revealed the presence of informational materials
(books) published by 'Mission Eurasia', which by Order No. 629-r of the
Justice Ministry of the Russian Federation of 13 May 2026, was included in
the List of foreign and international non-governmental organisations whose
activities have been declared undesirable", according to the court
decision.
These included: "Holistic Mission", "Evangelical Culture: History and
Modernity", "The Phenomenon of Leadership", "School Without Walls", "Steps
of Faith", "A Perspective on Theological Education", "Leadership in
Ministry", "Stars of the Reformation", "A Collection of Interviews with
Church, Ministry, and Mission Leaders and Ministry Experts", "Ministry to
Professional Communities", "Faith and Work", and "The Zohar" (in Aramaic).
Prosecutors interpreted the presence of these books as "participation by
the religious spiritual educational organisation of higher education
'Moscow Theological Seminary of Evangelical Christian-Baptists' in the
activities of [an undesirable organisation]', through the storage and
dissemination of informational materials (books) published by 'Mission
Eurasia'".
Judge Olga Ashurova noted that Mitskevich "has recently taken steps to
remedy the violations", and did not order the books to be destroyed.
Forum 18 wrote to the Prosecutor's Office of the Eastern Administrative
Okrug and Perovo District Court on 24 August to ask why the presence of
books in the library only two days after Mission Eurasia was added to the
register of "undesirable organisations" was considered grounds for
administrative prosecution. Forum 18 had received no response by the end of
the working day in Moscow of 31 August.
St Petersburg: Online discussion
A wide range of activity can lead to prosecution under Administrative Code
Article 20.33, even if it does not involve any direct interaction with the
"undesirable organisation" in question. In February and June 2026, Kirov
District Court in St Petersburg handed two Jehovah's Witnesses fines of
5,000 Roubles each. They were punished for discussing their faith using
resources from the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania, in
videos which investigators claim were posted on a Telegram channel.
The Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society is the Jehovah's Witnesses' main
publishing house, which produces and distributes religious literature
worldwide and maintains the main Jehovah's Witness website, jw.org. The
website was banned and blocked in Russia as "extremist" in 2015. Russia's
General Prosecutor's Office deemed the Watch Tower Society an "undesirable
organisation" on 12 October 2023, and the Justice Ministry added it to its
register of "undesirable organisations" on 8 November 2023.
In September 2024, Federal Security Service (FSB) investigators found two
videos on a Telegram channel in which three men "are conversing on the
topic of Jehovah's Witness beliefs, discussing religious dogma", according
to one of the court decisions, seen by Forum 18. One of three, Sergey
Oblakov, allegedly shared his computer screen, showing content from jw.org.
Investigators later found this to be "Lesson 42" from "Enjoy Life Forever!
An Interactive Bible Course: What the Bible Says About Marriage and
Singleness".
"The prosecutor's office construed this as the 'use and dissemination of
materials' and, accordingly, as participation in the activities of the
Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania", the European
Association of Jehovah's Witnesses told Forum 18 on 25 August. "Any
engagement with [the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society] – even talking
about one's faith on camera – is treated by the court as an offence."
The Telegram channel, "Researchers of Scripture" [Issledovateli Pisaniya]
stated in its profile that "We invite all believing brothers and sisters to
join in the study of Scripture", and used a tower as its profile picture.
Its address, cited in court documents seen by Forum 18, does not as of
August 2026 lead to a public or private channel. The channel is not
connected to either of the two men prosecuted, the European Association of
Jehovah's Witnesses told Forum 18 on 27 August, and is not officially
affiliated with the Jehovah's Witnesses.
Judge Darya Shmeleva found Oblakov guilty on 18 June 2026. He has lodged an
appeal at St Petersburg City Court, which is due to be heard on 9 September
2026.
Prosecutors also charged a second man whom the FSB identified in the
videos, Aleksandr Smirnov, with the same offence, although it is unclear
what material he is alleged to have shared, or whether he only engaged in
discussion of it. Judge Shmeleva found him guilty on 5 February 2026. He
appealed unsuccessfully on 8 April 2026.
Designating organisations "undesirable"
The process of designating organisations "undesirable"
(https://www.forum18.org/archi
Article 3.1 (adopted on 23 May 2015) of the 2012 Federal Law "On measures
of influence on persons involved in violations of fundamental human rights
and freedoms [and the] rights and freedoms of citizens of the Russian
Federation" (known as the Dima Yakovlev Law).
This legislation applies to foreign or international non-governmental
organisations which allegedly threaten Russia's constitutional order,
defence capabilities, or state security – explicitly including influence
on elections and referendums – or which are deemed to have acted as a
financial intermediary for an "undesirable organisation" already on the
list.
Once listed, an "undesirable organisation" must close all its branches in
Russia and is banned both from opening more and from founding any other
legal entities. It can no longer produce, distribute, or store any
informational materials, online or offline, and is barred from carrying out
any programmes or projects.
In 2021, Russian legal entities and citizens (plus stateless persons
resident in Russia) were barred from involvement with "undesirable
organisations" outside Russia (punishments for such involvement inside
Russia had already been in place since 2015). In 2024, further amendments
made it possible for organisations founded by foreign government bodies to
be placed on the register.
"Because the law does not clearly define the criteria for designating an
organization as 'undesirable', the authorities can, in effect, ban any
activity that runs counter to their interests under the guise of protecting
the constitutional order", human rights monitor OVD-Info notes
(https://ovdinfo.legal/instruc
"In practice, independent media outlets, as well as political, human
rights, religious, educational, research, and other projects, are
designated 'undesirable' for simply carrying out their lawful activities,"
OVD-Info adds.
The register currently has 391 entries, including more than 20 which are
religious bodies, religious media, missionary, or educational
organisations, or non-governmental organisations with religious links or
which promote freedom of religion and belief. These include: Jehovah's
Witness bodies from the US, Germany, and Ukraine; Brigham Young University
(which is sponsored by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints);
Friede Allen (Peace Unto All), which supports Russian clergy who have
opposed Russia's war in Ukraine; and seven Falun Gong or Falun Gong-linked
organisations. (END)
More reports on freedom of thought, conscience and belief in Russia
(https://www.forum18.org/archi
For background information see Forum 18's Russia religious freedom survey
(https://www.forum18.org/archi
Forum 18's compilation of Organisation for Security and Co-operation in
Europe (OSCE) freedom of religion or belief commitments
(https://www.forum18.org/archi
Follow us on Bluesky @Forum18
(https://bsky.app/profile/foru
Follow us on Facebook @Forum18NewsService
(https://www.facebook.com/Foru
Follow us on Telegram @Forum18NewsService
(https://telegram.me/s/forum18
Follow us on WhatsApp Forum 18
(https://www.whatsapp.com/chan
Follow us on X/Twitter @Forum_18 (https://x.com/forum_18)
All Forum 18 material may be referred to, quoted from, or republished in
full, if Forum 18 is credited as the source.